the speed of digital...
Friedman lists the things that didn't exist or were in their infancy in 2004: Facebook, Twitter, cloud computing, LinkedIn, 4G wireless, ultra-high-speed bandwith, big data, Skype, system-on-a-chip (SOC) circuits, iPhones, iPods, iPads and cellphone apps." Now, virtually everyone has, or will have soon, access to a tablet or cellphone which can be activated by voice or touch, and which is connected via the cloud to infinite applications and storage.
Here's the rub, though, as Friedman points out: "Every boss now also has cheaper, easier, faster access to more above-average software, automation, robotics, cheap labor and cheap genius than ever before."
And here's the big uh-oh: "Everyone who wants a job now must demonstrate how they can add value better than the new alternatives." In the "old days" it was assumed that your educational foundation would last your whole lifetime. Not true now, though...
In church music and worship ministry, like almost every other profession, the level of skills required for a good job is rising inexorably. Digital tools are not only reinventing themselves so that the obsolescence cycle seems to be the duration of your cell phone contract, but in an unfair flip side of that Moore's Law reality, the expectations for people in the workplace are rising even faster than the tools can be built.
The sad truth, as Erik Brynjolfsson of Massachusetts Institute of Technology puts it, is that those with more education start to earn much more than those without it, those with the capital to buy the tools earn much more than those who can just offer their labor, and those with superstar skills, who have more (even global) reach, earn much more than those with less talent.
This last is important, because, for the "relevant" churches, the Sunday morning pendulum has been steadily moving away from those with traditional music education, and toward those with "star power." In the process, it seems, it is less about how well you can teach, minister, and serve, and more about how many fan(nie)s you put in the seats. Is it any wonder that in a large percentage of American churches, worship seems like a concert that is interrupted by a talk?
Lest you think I am just preaching doom and gloom, I want to make it clear that the pendulum, at the very least is moving more slowly, and I believe that a leader's ability, and, more importantly, willingness, to use digital tools (and good old fashioned analog ones like pipe organs and relational skills) can level the playing field. But the time has come to quit complaining about why this isn't the "good old days," and start adapting to the realities of modern worship and ministry.
In the meantime, I'll leave the last word to Friedman, who says: "The winners won't just be those with more IQ. It will also be those with more PQ (passion quotient) and CQ (curiosity quotient) to leverage all the new digital tools to not just find a job, but to invent one or reinvent one, and to not just learn but to relearn for a lifetime." That statement is just as true in post-pandemic 2021 as it was a decade ago.
© 2014, 2021 All Rights Reserved
4 Replies to “Hyperconnectivity and Music and Worship Ministry”
Yes Vern, I would agree. I think there is a tremendous advantage in understanding recording, lighting, and all the digital technology that goes with the new church. A college music industry degree may be more valuable currently than a music education degree. One small rural church has a huge following just through their podcast. At the same time, if you were to ask me who most influenced my life it would not be someone known to me as a talking head.
I’m not even sure a music industry degree in and of itself is the “answer” Steve. Tech changes so fast these days that I think you have to know how to communicate with the tech guys so they can understand what you want musically and not get run over by their “presets.” I also agree with you on the talking head part (although Walter Cronkite was very influential at the time), but I do know that a significant percentage of people now attend church by turning on their flat screen. I think that’s more toothpaste that can’t be put back in the tube…
Ministry is so much more than technology. I do my best to keep up (having teenagers in the house helps) but ministry is still about the relationships we create with one another as we labor side by side for the Kingdom of God. Use the individuals you have in whatever church you serve – don’t shy away from technology if you have talented volunteers who can help in those areas but don’t let technology lead your ministry. Your ministry should be led by the Holy Spirit.
Great wisdom Anita.
Comments are closed.